Boston Top Doctors: Community Hospitals

SAY YOU DISCOVER a suspicious lump, find out you’re pregnant, or injure your shoulder. Should you head to a Boston hospital?

[sidebar]Not necessarily. These days, Longwood Avenue isn’t the only place to get top-notch care. As competition for patients and healthcare dollars heats up, community hospitals have become increasingly sophisticated, says David Ball, a Newton-based healthcare consultant. Most have a network of “affiliations” — arrangements under which major academic medical centers (the Beth Israels and Mass Generals of the world) send their specialists out to the ’burbs to see patients and cover shifts. Children’s Hospital pediatricians, for instance, treat the kids who end up in Winchester Hospital’s emergency room; physicians from Dana-Farber and Brigham and Women’s help guide South Shore Hospital’s oncology care. The upshot? Simply by seeing these docs at your local hospital rather than downtown, you’ll often pay less. Teaching hospitals collected, on average, 38 percent more than community hospitals for comparable cases, according to a 2010 report from the Massachusetts Council of Community Hospitals. Specifically, rates for routine care delivered at MGH or Brigham and Women’s ran 66 percent higher, says Edward Moscovitch, who authored the study. (Investigate for yourself at Massachusetts Healthcare Quality and Cost Council.)

If your condition is rare and serious, going downtown might remain your best bet. But for most of us needing relatively common procedures, chances are a community hospital can do things better, because patient care is its only focus. “The major academic centers also have to juggle a research and teaching mission–sometimes that helps with care, but not always,” notes Sara Singer, assistant professor of healthcare management and policy at the Harvard School of Public Health. Another benefit? Staying close to home can alleviate stress and increase the likelihood you’ll get timely follow-up care. Here are eight facilities that deliver the same exceptional medical care found in Boston.


Beth Israel Deaconess Hospital–Needham
Beds  | 58   
Specialties  | Emergency care, orthopedics, urology

Since becoming a suburban outpost of Beth Israel in 2002, the former Glover Hospital has the diagnostic muscle of the big boys — without the gridlock. “Because we’re small and used to working together, communication flows easily,” says chief nursing officer Penny Greenberg, who moved from the Boston flagship five years ago and now runs Needham’s nursing staff. Daily rounds are a group affair: Nurses, plus a social worker, physical therapist, nutritionist, and spiritual adviser all weigh in. In a new wing of all-private rooms, call buttons ring to nurses’ cell phones. As a result, the hospital has a near-zero rate of patients developing bedsores, an indicator of care quality. The facility, once cash-strapped, has been upgraded in ways that make tapping the expertise and resources of the downtown Beth Israel even easier. The new million-dollar MRI, CAT, and digital mammography suite, for instance, is electronically linked to the main campus, allowing specialists to give a second opinion. And Needham’s state-of-the-art emergency department has 19 treatment bays, ER docs from downtown, and a layout that puts crucial equipment (like ventilators) near the ambulance entrance. It also has stabilization and rapid-transit procedures for getting critical cases to Boston.

Emerson Hospital
Beds | 179  
Specialties | Oncology, emergency care, maternity care

As the story goes, it grieved Charles Emerson each time he took his ailing wife, Theresa, to Brookline by horse and buggy to have her cough treated. Shortly after Theresa’s death in 1910, the nephew of author Ralph Waldo granted 40 acres and $20,000 to build a hospital that to this day serves a grateful swath of MetroWest from Wayland to Groton. In fact, the hospital is so popular with neighbors that there’s actually a waitlist to be a candy striper. A wellness and education center, offering everything from nutrition counseling to support groups for caregivers, is set to open this spring. Of course, people get sick, and when they do, Emerson has experts at hand: neuro-surgeons from the Lahey Clinic, perinatologists from Brigham and Women’s (for high-risk pregnancies), and radiation oncologists from Mass General. The hospital’s Bethke Cancer Center has a state-of-the-art linear accelerator, which better targets cancerous cells with less collateral damage to healthy tissue. The center also offers complementary therapies, including massage, acupuncture, and Reiki. Another patient benefit? Along with handmade hats for newborns and bears for sick kids, the volunteer auxiliary here stitches quilts for those undergoing chemo and radiation.

Newton-Wellesley Hospital
Beds  | 307
Specialties  | Oncology, disease screening, orthopedics, bariatric surgery

The Newton-Wellesley area has a hospital to match its premium schools and real estate values. A member of Partners HealthCare, the hospital shares physicians and technology with sister institutions Mass General and Brigham and Women’s. If you arrive unresponsive at the ER in Newton, your entire computerized medical history can be pulled up onscreen instantly (results, images, physician notes — even if they were done years ago at MGH or Brigham). Another system tracks every drug order, flagging potential interactions, errors, and duplications. Each patient — and every pill — gets a barcode; if the info doesn’t match up at bedside, the dose isn’t given. Newton-Wellesley is among the fewer than one percent of hospitals nationwide that use cutting-edge genetic screening to assess an individual’s risks for certain types of cancer. Yet while the high-tech is impressive, so is the low-tech. The mission is to reduce stress (known to be a negative influence on health) for all visitors, which means greeters will not only give you directions, they’ll also escort you to an appointment when needed. If you have a questionable mammogram, you’ll get an immediate follow-up. “We try to get you a diagnosis within 48 hours. If you find out you’ve got a positive finding on Monday, you’ll be meeting with a team by Wednesday or Thursday to discuss a care plan,” says Michael S. Jellinek, president of Newton-Wellesley Hospital and chief of child psychiatry at Mass General. “We don’t tolerate anything that increases the patient’s anxiety.”  

  • Ronald

    Really?? North of Boston is Lahey and Winchester?? Lahey I might go along with… but what about North Shore Medical Center and Beverly Hospital. Both top notch places that were left off you list.