Best of Boston

BEST Pies

2014 BEST Pies

Petsi Pies

When it comes to pie, we like our hand-pressed crusts substantial and loaded to the brink with butter. So too does Petsi, and the Somerville and Cambridge shops augment their expertly sound pie foundations with just-as-serious fillings—blueberries with a big… read more»

2009 BEST Pies, Fruit

Petsi Pies

Somerville

Only the most flavorful morsels of perfectly ripe, sweet fruits make the cut for Renee McLeod’s blueberry, mixed berry, and tart cherry crumb desserts. We’re pie-eyed with love. read more»

1999 BEST Pies, Apple

Trudie’s Treats-Homemade Treasures

If it’s possible for a Scandinavian apple pie to be better than an American one, Trudie’s Swedish apple pie takes the cake. The secret: sweet, juicy apples, nuts to keep it crunchy, and a crust made with real butter. You… read more»

1999 BEST Pies, Boston Cream

2129

Charlestown

It seems that Boston cream pie is the tiramisu of the ’60s—once ubiquitous, now vanished from most restaurant dessert cards. But chef Billy Boudreau has salvaged the once august reputation of what should be a hometown fixture. He bakes individual… read more»

1997 BEST Pies, Blueberry

Dogwood Cafe

Jamaica Plain

When snowy nights descend upon us again, there’s only one thing to do: Revel in them. Tramp over to the Dogwood Cafe in Jamaica Plain and order up a hot, crisp, and gooey blueberry pie a la mode. Winter weight… read more»

1997 BEST Pies, Boston Cream

Mike’s Pastry

Boston

Boston cream pies are all about ratios: cake to chocolate, chocolate to cream, cream to cake. At Mike’s Pastry in the North End, somebody did their algebra homework. More like a cake than a pie, Mike’s rendition brings together equal… read more»

1996 BEST Pies, Apple

Greenhills Irish Bakery

Dorchester

The crust is thicker than usual—almost cobbler-like—flaky and delicious, holding loads of fresh apples; this pie is terrific. We like it Irish-style, without cinnamon. It’s also a bargain, at $6 for a 10-inch pie. read more»

1996 BEST Pies, Spinach

Lolly’s Bakery

Boston

A double-crusted round pie, stuffed with spinach, onions, and a hint of cheese, and cut into wedges. It’s filling and very good. read more»

1995 BEST Pies, Boston Cream

Bentonwood Bakery/Cafe

Newton Centre

This classic not-really-a-pie has three parts: cake, custard, and chocolate frosting. Bentonwood’s version is unconventional—individual, cupcake-size BCPs, a circle of cake topped with a creamy custard, all hidden underneath a bittersweet-chocolate glaze, but terrific. read more»

1980 BEST Pies, Boston Cream

Montilio’s

Boston

read more»