Picco

Previous years have seen this contest split into mini categories like "Best Thin Crust" and "Best Toppings." But it's time to set aside compiled-ish things and commit to a single, superlative winner: namely, Picco, for combining the chewy-crisp crust of Santarpio's with the fresh (okay, "gourmet") toppings that have earned Emma's such a devoted following. It's the best of both worlds on a 14-inch disk of dough, and you won't find its match in the city. RUNNER-UP: Emma's LAST YEAR: N/A