Will the Internet Find Maura Murray?

Ten years ago, a 21-year-old UMass student vanished without a trace. For an army of amateur sleuths across the Internet, that was just the beginning.

Strelzin knows firsthand how citizen sleuths can solve a mystery. In 2003, he worked the case of a Concord, New Hampshire, man who kidnapped and killed his two children. Once apprehended, the man refused to divulge the location of the buried bodies, and hanged himself in his jail cell. After his death, private citizens formed search groups and traveled to the area authorities believed the children were buried. “I would communicate with some of those groups, share information, send pictures back and forth,” Strelzin says. Eventually, one of the searchers found the children’s bodies just off the highway in Hudson, Ohio.

In Maura Murray’s case, Strelzin will not say how often law enforcement monitors online forums, but concedes that the police are “aware of things that are said.” He adds that “nothing fruitful” has ever come from the DIY detectives.

“All we ask is that they do not interfere in the investigations,” Strelzin continues. “You would expect that if people had information they would contact the authorities.”

 

From the sprawling online world of the Maura Murray mystery—filled with anonymous commenters, trolls, and theorists—a freelance journalist, using his real name, had emerged, determined to crack the case. In the summer of 2010, James Renner, a former reporter for a weekly newspaper called the Cleveland Scene, saw an episode of 20/20 on Maura. “I just thought, Wow, I wonder if I could figure it out,” Renner says. He began posting on message boards, and launched his own blog, My Search for Maura Murray, in June 2011. Eventually, he had so much information up on the site—from minuscule facts to big theories—that he decided to begin working on a manuscript.

Renner has just completed a 300-page book about his search for Maura, and can rattle off minute details about the case as if they were baseball stats. During his investigation, Renner wrote on his site that he discovered that just three months before her disappearance, Maura was visited by police officers at her dorm on account of $79.02 she had spent on pizza deliveries with a stolen credit card number. He also wrote that records indicated the charges would be dropped within three months under one condition: Maura would have to stay out of trouble until then. Could her late-night car accident, after drinking at a party, have brought those charges back into play? Renner believes that Maura ran away—and that she may still be alive. This past December, he traveled through Quebec following up on a lead he read on a message board in 2009 about Maura being in Sherbrooke—a town near the New Hampshire border. He posted flyers with Maura’s photo along the way, and while he says he got some tantalizing leads, none panned out. Sherbrooke joined places like Montreal; Toronto; Hillsboro, New Hampshire; and Barton, Vermont on the long list of spots where Maura had supposedly been spotted, but never found.

Renner also questions whether Fred may be standing in the way of finding his daughter. On his blog, Renner has speculated that the father knows more than he is letting on, and he theorizes that Fred may know why Maura went to New Hampshire, even if he may not know where she is now. “Whether he helped her or not, I don’t know,” Renner says.

After hearing about numerous accusatory posts on Renner’s blog, Fred refused to cooperate for the book. He believes his daughter was abducted by “a local dirtbag” and rejects the notion that she was running away. “She didn’t have any reason,” Fred says. “She had things going for her. She was going to be a nurse. She was getting a new car—a three-year-old car—the very next Saturday. She was getting married soon. She was getting great marks.”

The feud between Renner and Murray has become personal.“What I think he’s trying to do is create characters for a screenplay,” Fred says of Renner. “I have spent countless hours. Every possible trail. You wouldn’t believe the places I’ve been in.” For his part, Renner finds Murray’s behavior suspicious.

“In the history of missing women, what father has ever not wanted more publicity about their missing daughter?” Renner says.

Fred says he’s waiting to see the book before he responds to it. “From what I hear,” he says, “there’s a lot of false insinuations.”

Renner says he would welcome a lawsuit from Fred Murray. “There’s nothing that would please me more than to depose Fred in court under oath,” Renner says. “Everything in the book is factual and backed up with documentation.”

“He wants me to be a subplot, ’cause I didn’t talk to him,” Fred counters. “I can take temporary hits. That’s losing battles. But there’s a war.”

For Helena Murray, the downsides of citizen sleuthing have come to outweigh the benefits.“It’s terribly, terribly sad to see what they do to [Fred] online,” she says. Helena even took down the message board on her site, mauramurraymissing.com, when visitors’ attacks became too sharp.

“I don’t really give a shit about that crap,” Fred says. “That’s a sideshow. The deal is: Where is my daughter?”

  • jamesrenner

    If you’re interested in reading the police reports related to Maura’s disappearance and other info, including her affair with a UMass track coach during which she spoke about starting a new life, following this link: http://mauramurray.blogspot.com/p/what-weve-learned-so-far.html

    • Phaerisee

      Thanks for that information. I thought it was interesting that the dogs apparently lost the scent within 100 yards, and that the bus driver lived within 100 yards of the site of the accident. I am not saying he had anything to do with it, but I wonder if he was asked to voluntarily take a polygraph. The rag in the tailpipe seems like it could be the key to the case or just one of the seemingly endless anomalous coincidences. If it were not for the rag, I would not suspect the father at all. But since he was the one who apparently introduced the rag according to his words that throws suspicion on him. I really get the feeling though, just based on the statistical probabilities, that perhaps they ought to consider a more comprehensive interrogation of the bus driver.

      • jamesrenner

        The bus driver took two lie detector tests. Supposedly he failed the first one but passed the second. He had a lot of health problems and died a few years ago. IMHO, I don’t think he had anything to do with her disappearance.

      • dnelliganvisionlandscaping

        Was the bus driver’s property ever thoroughly searched? If not, why? I thought I heard the father was not allowed on his property, (not sure if this was accurate or not). My first suspicion was with the bus driver also. What questions varied on the polygraph? This has haunted me from the beginning; if a search party is put together, count me in!

      • j23o

        I’m sure you cannot drive a car with a rag shoved in the exhaust,the engine would die pretty quickly because of back pressure.Did they analyse the rag to see if there was carbon deposits on it? or was it shoved in to stop her getting away?was the car driveable after the accident or was there major mechanical damage.I think she was a bit drunk and just lost control.

  • Glenn Adams

    http://onlineathens.com/local-news/2012-09-17/familys-perseverance-social-networking-led-recovery-missing-athens-woman

    Family’s perseverance, social networking led to recovery of missing Athens woman

    By JOE JOHNSONupdated Monday, September 17, 2012 – 9:11pm

    After several harrowing weeks out on her own while authorities considered her an endangered missing person, 25-year-old Ivy Dawn Merck recently returned home with her parents.

    Steven Merck on Monday described how he and his wife, Sally, found their daughter while passing out missing person fliers in Florida as they searched for the University of Georgia graduate who intentionally disappeared from her Athens home.

    “It’s unbelievable,” Steven Merck said via telephone from his home in Camden County. “We were riding down the road in Miami when we saw about five or six police officers on bikes, and Sally said we should stop and give them some fliers.

    “They told us to go to the police station and leave fliers there, and when we got to the Miami police station, Ivy was just there, sitting on the steps,” Steven Merck said.

    “We just kind of stared at her, and she was in a state of shock. Then we all started running to her, and we all must’ve hugged for 10 minutes before we started talking.”

    When she went missing, Merck was struggling with personal problems. Authorities who investigated her disappearance concluded from notes she left and other evidence that the woman might be suicidal.

    Authorities spoke with Merck’s family members on Thursday and prepared them for a possible tragic outcome.

    That same day, Merck’s sister-in-law got an idea from Websleuths.com, an Internet virtual community that follows and comments about missing persons cases and unsolved crimes. She and her husband, Chad Merck, both had registered with Websleuths.com to spread the word about the missing woman.

    Someone posted on the website that the family should create a Facebook page devoted to the search. Stephanie Baker-Merck responded, “Excellent idea. I’m going to start working on this right now.”

    The page was up and running that night. Because Merck’s birthday was the following day, authorities and family members urged people to post birthday greetings with the hope Merck might read them and realize how many people cared for her and were concerned.

    “We created this page to give people a place to express their concern for Ivy and show her how much she is loved and valued by family, friends and the community,” Baker-Merck said. “We made this page with her birthday in mind, but we would have done it regardless.”

    Ivy Merck actually saw the special Facebook page and read Websleuth.com discussions about her, which got her thinking about contacting her family.

    In a Websleuths.com post Sunday afternoon, Chad Merck explained the rest:

    “(Ivy) had gone to the (University) of Miami library the day before, because it was a safe place to go during the day,” Chad Merck posted. “She used a computer and had seen the ‘Find Ivy Dawn Merck’ Facebook page and the Websleuth blog posts.

    “She realized that she needed to come home at that point. She said she set out (for) the police station this morning, but went the wrong way and got lost. She passed several pay phones, but could not bring herself to make a call.”

    That was at about the same time Ivy Merck’s parents ran into the bicycle officers in Miami.

    “(Ivy) had arrived at the station 10 minutes prior and was trying to bring herself to head inside. You can imagine her shock at seeing my parents in the flesh,” Chad Merck said in his Internet posting.

    “I am not a statistician, but the odds of us arriving at the same location in Miami at the same time must be incredible,” he wrote. “There is no other way to explain such an amazing coincidence, other than as an answered prayer.”

    The family initially searched in the Deerfield Beach area, because that’s where authorities found the missing woman’s car. Chad Merck explained on Websleuths.com that the family decided to expand the search to Miami because a “generic” address in Miami was the last location his sister had entered into her car’s GPS.

    The Merck family’s ordeal started shortly after Aug. 21, when she told her roommate and supervisor at Good Hands Veterinary Hospital in Oconee County that she was leaving to visit her parents.

    She boarded her dog in the Camden County community of Kingsland on Aug. 23, but never arrived at her parents’ house. That’s when Steven Merck filed a missing persons report with Athens-Clarke police.

    Authorities listed Merck as a missing person in state and national law enforcement databases, and on Aug. 30, a sheriff’s deputy in Florida’s Broward County found Merck’s car in a parking lot in Deerfield Beach, just south of Boca Raton and about 350 miles from Kingsland.

    The car had just about run out of gas, authorities said, and the tires were so bald the car couldn’t be driven and had to be towed.

    According to Chad Merck’s Websleuths.com postings, his sister appeared to have lived in the car because blankets were inside.

    After learning his sister had entered a Miami location in her car’s GPS, Chad Merck decided the city’s South Beach would be a good place to continue the search, he said in his online post.

    “I had visited Miami a few times and figured that you find your way to South Beach at some point,” he said. “If Ivy did come to Miami, then it was worth a shot.”

    There was no parking available, so the man dropped off his parents on South Beach’s main drag, and they later went to the beach and left fliers at lifeguard stations before their son picked them up, Chad Merck said in his post.

    The family felt frustrated and was about to drive back to Deerfield beach when Sally Merck spotted the officers on bicycle patrol.

    “We headed over there, and I dropped my parents off,” Chad Merck said. “I called my wife and was lamenting how futile our search had been that day. We had no leads at all. My mom then called me, so I switched over, and she said the words, ‘We found Ivy. Come now.’

    “I then ran towards the police station, and there were my parents hugging and sobbing over a very stunned Ivy,” he said. “She looked the same, except she had cut her hair shorter and dyed in blondish. She was tanner and a bit sunburned from overexposure to the sun, and was visibly trembling. All she had with her was a ratty knapsack with some clothes in it.”

    On the drive to their hotel room, the family members learned about Ivy Merck’s ordeals over the previous three weeks.

    “Ivy … survived sleeping on the beach and had several people that helped her at key times with food and protection,” Chad Merck said in his Websleuths.com posting.

    “I am sure there were many harrowing experiences over these weeks on the street, but God provided protection for her to leave unharmed physically,” he said.

    “Ivy had her laptop, money and most of her belongings stolen in separate instances, but she survived the experience and was reunited with family. Our family is overjoyed with the outcome.”

    Steven Merck did not know if or when his daughter would return to Athens, because seeing to her emotional needs comes first.

    “We’re going to take care of her and do whatever it takes to get Ivy back to society and back to just being Ivy,” he said.

    • Follow Criminal Justice reporter Joe Johnson atwww.facebook.com/JoeJohnsonABH or http://www.twitter.com/JoeJohnsonABH.

    Wolfscratch/Foxfire

  • LP29

    Seriously show her face, this is a ridiculous joke and disrespectful to the family. Why would you not show her face, she is MISSING!!!!

  • Polly Penwell

    Wow!! THAT’s INSULTING!! It’s a perfect example of the IGNORANT and ARROGANT attitude that makes law enforcement so unpopular in this country.

    “DIY detectives” have solved cases more than once where law enforcement have failed to do so. In fact, a “DIY Detective” just this past month solved a 30-year-old missing persons case in TEN MINUTES that somehow managed to elude law enforcement for over three decades.

    And while we are busy “not being fruitful” do you want us to “contact the authorities” with information? Or do you want us to “not interfere in the investigation?” PICK ONE!!!!

    ——-

    Re: quote:

    In Maura Murray’s case, Strelzin will not say how often law enforcement monitors online forums, but concedes that the police are “aware of things that are said.” He adds that “nothing fruitful” has ever come from the DIY detectives.

    “All we ask is that they do not interfere in the investigations,” Strelzin continues. “You would expect that if people had information they would contact the authorities.”

  • Polly Penwell

    Undo. Undo. (Sigh)

    Sorry. Too much caffeine, not enough reading.

  • Jo Anna Lee Ball
  • Epter

    Good article on a vexing case. I couldn’t help but notice that notwithoutperil was deleted today. Was “samledyard” expecting to be identified by name, or was this a doxxing? In any event, there would be news value to naming interested websleuthers and contextualizing their interest, but I wonder if work as an atty is complicated by a sleuthing hobby. In any event, I’ve been following this for the past few months as an objective observer and this was a really balanced, informative take on the multiple perspectives on the case that acknowledged the weird online turf wars in the weeds without getting stuck in them.

  • johnallore

    Fascinating piece. Some thoughts:
    1. If theorists really do believe Maura went to Canada, specifically Sherbrooke, I wonder if they are aware there is a monastery there, Abbaye St. Benoit Du Lac, that might have provided refuge. In fact, my father knocked on their door 35 years ago when my sister went missing.
    2. Maura’s father, Fred Murray and I have corresponded over the years. He may now feel she was abducted by “a local dirtbag”, but for a time he took the notion of her fleeing to Canada very seriously. I know because I put him in contact with some police investigators with the Quebec police.
    3. I have also corresponded with James Renner. I respect James’ tenacity, but his comment that Fred Murray must be hiding something because, “In the history of missing women, what father has ever not wanted more publicity about their missing daughter?” is unfair, irresponsible, and simply not accurate. When my sister disappeared, authorities accused her of being everything from mentally disturbed, to a runaway, to a “lesbian” (heaven forbid). At that point, the very LAST thing my parents wanted was more publicity. They felt betrayed by the people they supposed were there to help them, and so they shut up. This is exactly what Fred has done, and I don’t blame him one bit.
    4. I am pretty sure I was one of the first blogs to start covering this story beginning around 2004.
    J Allore
    http://www.theresaallore.com

  • j23o

    Having watched the programme more than once I think the whole case was kicked off by that 1am upsetting phone call she received which she never confided to anyone the of the content.She became irrational after that.We know there was no family problems so could that phone call have been a secret love interest.Was she being told it was over?or a death?At the accident scene she had obviously been drinking alcohol mixed with coke while driving and threw it away afterwards. Why did she purchase so much alcohol in the first place.?I think she fell victim to an opportunist sexual abduction.Why did the police not let loose the scent dogs on that bus that passed?anyone would feel safe being picked up in a well lit bus.Wasn’t Ariel Castro a bus driver?something to dwell on.This case was always intrigueing because there was a lot of unexplained things going on before the disappearance.

    • Throckmorton

      The bus driver that “passed” lived within one hundred feet of where her car was found. I think you have the right idea.

      • http://festivals4fun.com/ Viveta Mentze

        This still doesn’t make sense you guys.. if you use Occam’s Razor correctly, you’d see this isn’t the most likely theory at all.. In fact its very UNLIKELY… You are basically saying its likely that within minutes of the crash, the bus driver in the small window of time kidnapped and killed the girl, somehow had her disappear without a trace, and rather than spending time to go over what he would say called police to report it, rather than making working on clean up, an alibi, etc. you are saying the most likely scenario was that he did all that, and called police as soon as he got home. If this is the most likely scenario, how did he do all this in a short period of time, why was he the one who called the police, why haven’t police or the girl’s family expressed belief that he is hiding something, how come we haven’t heard of a failed lie detector test by him; or a refusal to take one (which would be the “most likely” possibilities if he were involved.. I could go on and on… The point is, all the things I mentioned above highlight why this is not the MOST LIKELY SCENARIO and why you aren’t using Occam’s Razor correctly if you think the bus driver was most likely involved…

  • Throckmorton

    Some friends and I have been taking a look at this. Everything is pointing to the bus driver in our opinion, and the theory is that he tampered with the car, and anticipated the accident and was waiting for it.

    • elizabeth

      nah…. read more about it. the bus driver was completely cleared by police. i think if he were at all suspicious they would have been completely on him from the get-go

    • http://festivals4fun.com/ Viveta Mentze

      I agree with Elizabeth, it doesn’t seem at all likely it was the bus driver at all. He was the one that called police as soon as he got home, and the timeline backs up his story; the lady who first heard the crash was minutes prior, not enough time to do anything sinister. Also, the first call was made by the woman so you know the time roughly that the crash initially happened, the bus driver comes across the crash talks for a few minutes, then heads straight home and makes the SECOND call to 911 and dispatchers arrive there. He would have had no time to take her anywhere if he was involved and then call 911 so quickly from his house (which would have been idiotic if he was involved besides to call the police right away),

  • Samuel Ledyard

    We’re rebuilding the blog.

    The first post is a response to this great article. Please feel free to share your thoughts. http://notwithoutperil.com/2014/02/17/the-internet-will-find-maura-murray/

  • joeb

    Fred knows more than he’s saying like why she was going where she was going.
    However it does not take alot of crime solving skills to know that she was abducted, listen people dont vanish within 10 minutes. We may never know the abductors identity.
    But clearly she didnt abduct herself!

    • http://festivals4fun.com/ Viveta Mentze

      Joeb has it all figured out! lol. moron. Fred is the guy pressing to have ALL the information released and went to court for this to happen! Also he visits the area every weekend and was on countless tv shows to keep the story alive in hopes of finding his daughter.. Yet JoeStupid here believes the father is hiding info.. Yawn. They did this to John Walsh too when his son was kidnapped and murdered.. you people are really sick to go after a family in mourning without SOLID evidence! Great work Sherlock!

  • jenn

    I think they should go to a psychic a legit one to give them some answers.. Idk that’s what I would do..

  • phychics arent real

    Yes jenn, that’s a great idea! Because there is totally a big difference between a legit psychic and a regular old
    Phychic …… right? Ha ha

  • Laura Zamora

    !!! How (Dr.Goodluck) Help Me Save My Marriage & Avoid Divorce !!!

    i can’t really believe that i am with my Ex-Husband after when he broke up with me with 3 kids i thank Dr Goodluck of (goodluck05spellcaster@gmail.com) for helping me getting back my man back, My Name is Laura Zamora from England and my man name is Mr Raymond, my happiness turn to bitterness,my joy turn to sorrow,my love turn to hate when my husband broke up with me last week,i was so frustrated and i could not know what next to do again, i was so unthinkable and i could not concentrate any more, i love my husband so much but he was cheating on me with another woman and this makes him broke up with me so that he can be able to get marry to the other lady and this lady i think cast a spell on my husband to make him hate me and my kids and this was so critical and uncalled-for,I cry all day and night for God to send me a helped to get back my man until i went to Westmoreland to see a friend and who was having he same problem with me but she latter got her Husband back and i asked her how she was able to get her husband back and she told me that their was a powerful spell caster in Africa name DR Goodluck that he help with love spell in getting back lost lover’s back and i decided to contacted the same Dr Goodluck and he told me what is needed to be done for me to have my man back and i did it although i doubted it but i did it and the Dr told me that i will get the result after 24hours, and he told me that my husband was going to call me by 9pm in my time and i still doubted his word, to my surprise my husband really called me and told me that he miss me so much Oh My God i was so happy, and today i am happily with my man again and we are joyfully living together as one good family and i thank the powerful spell caster Dr Goodluck of goodluck05spellcaster@gmail.com, he is so powerful and i decided to share my story on the internet that good spell casters still exist and Dr Goodluck is one of the good spell caster who i will always pray to live long to help his children in the time of trouble, if you are there and your lover is turning you down, or you have your husband moved to another woman, do not cry anymore contact the powerful spell caster Dr Goodluck on his email: goodluck05spellcaster@gmail.com and he will answer you, i am a living testimony and i will continue to testify of his goodness in my family,he turn my family to paradise and today we are all happy together Dr Goodluck i say thank you in one million times thanks Dr.also contact him on his web site http://goodluck05spellcaster.yolasite.com

  • Frank Silver

    HELLO i have read testimonies about this great spell caster called Dr. Ekpiku how he helped people to bring their lover back. so i decide to give him a try, i am here today to give my own testimony on how this great man brought my ex back within 48 hours for just to contact him. this girl has broke up with me over 6 weeks but she came back just within 48 hours that Dr Ekpiku said he will make her come back to me. just contact this man and he will bring your ex back here is his email address mail. Ekpikuspelltemple@live.com

  • Lizzy Patrick

    I never knew people still have powers and make things happened this way. my boyfriend LENON STAIN left me for another girl for three months’ ever since then my life have been filled with pains sorrow and heart break because he was my first love who disvirgin me when i was 21 years old. about two years ago, A friend of mine LANA told me he saw some testimonies of this great Dr AGBAGIE that he can bring back lover within some few days, i laugh it out and said i am not interested but because of the love my friend had for me, she consulted the great priest on my behalf and to my greatest surprise after three days my boyfriend called me for the very first time after three months that he is missing me and that he is so sorry for every thing he made me went through and as i speak right now we are happily married. i still can’t believe it, because it highly unbelievable it just too real to be real. Thank you Dr AGBAGIE for bringing back my lover and also to my lovely friend who interceded on my behalf, for any one who might need the help of this great priest here is the email address:(agbagietemple@gmail.com) or you can call the great man on (+2348052849204). good luck