Real Estate

Either-Or: A Connecticut Cape vs. Charlestown’s Cutest Condo

It’s amazing what a few miles will do to the market. This month, we compare a graceful Cape near New Haven with a centuries-old Charlestown abode.

Photos by Jake Wyman (Connecticut); William Raveis R.E. & Home Services (Charlestown)

35 State Street, Guilford, ConnecticutSale Price: $810,0005 Salem Street, Charlestown
2,574 square feet
Asking Price
Days on Market
1,080 square feet

Historical charm with modern conveniences. what more could a New Englander ask for? In addition to an original hearth, this classic 1828 Cape near New Haven, Connecticut, offered buyers recently updated plumbing and heating systems, as well as a breezy screened-in porch. All of those amenities, plus four roomy bedrooms and an in-law apartment, ultimately commanded $315 per square foot.

Over in Charlestown, a 19th-century condo less than half the size struck a similar balance of present-day creature comforts and Old World style, but for a whopping $750 per square foot. Exposed-brick walls, beamed ceilings, and original pumpkin-pine floors circa 1865 made the new built-ins and mod mudroom stand out even more at showings, leading the home to fly off the market in a month’s time, for $91,000 over asking price. And though this two-bed beauty isn’t within arms’ reach of a pastoral town green, it does offer two slices of outdoor paradise for its new owners: a brick patio and a roof deck with skyline views.


The Boston Home team has curated a list of the best home design and home remodeling professionals in Boston, including home builders and contractors, interior designers, home accent décor, and more. Get the help you need with FindIt/Boston's guide to home renovation pros.