Real Estate

Either-Or: A Sprawling Scituate Chateau vs. a South End Triplex

It’s amazing what a few miles will do to the market. This month, we compare a riverfront South Shore estate with a three-floor condo in the city.

Photos by Bill Good Sr., Bill Good Jr., and Lynn Murphy/Dean and Hamilton Realtors (Scituate); Boston Virtual Imaging (South End)

169 Border Street, ScituateSale Price: $3,000,000228 West Canton Street, #1, Boston
5,165 square feet
Asking Price
Days on Market
2,597 square feet

Acres of lawn in the suburbs, or a petite patio and deck in the heart of the South End? These recently sold properties each offer their own take on al fresco living. Though nestled along a South Shore riverbank, the stonework-clad estate in Scituate could just as easily belong on the French Riviera, with 7 acres of pear trees, lush lawns, and four-season gardens gracing the grounds. Inside, a luxe kitchen boasts a huge hexagonal island with built-in storage—not to mention a light, bright, conservatory-style dining area perfect for sipping mimosas on sunny Sunday mornings.

Twenty-five miles away, a South End triplex has about half the square footage of its Scituate counterpart, though an open floor plan and 10-foot ceilings make every level feel spacious. As for outdoor spaces? A private deck with skyline views juts out from the brick building’s bow-front façade, while the garden level features a postage-stamp patio with a turf floor that looks like impeccably manicured grass at first glance—even more so after a few of those mimosas.


The Boston Home team has curated a list of the best home design and home remodeling professionals in Boston, including home builders and contractors, interior designers, home accent décor, and more. Get the help you need with FindIt/Boston's guide to home renovation pros.