House of Curiosities

Two ex-urbanites bring their eclectic sense of style to a 19th-century Greek Revival in Newburyport.

Jenn Clapp newburyport collectors home

The exposed wooden beams and painted floor in the open dining and kitchen area came with the house, but the Clapps brought the flamed birch dining table (custom-made by Staples Cabinetmakers), Modernica chairs, and a Nelson saucer pendant from Design Within Reach. (Photographs by Bob O’Connor)

The move was born from that eternal complaint among thirtysomething city dwellers: too much stuff and too little space. Compared with the compact apartment they’d had in Charlestown, Jenn and Greg Clapp thought the 2,200-square-foot Greek Revival on a tree-lined street in Newburyport—with not just one driveway, but two—felt entirely self-indulgent. And totally perfect. “The first thing I did was unpack boxes of useless objects,” says Jenn, an interior designer at the Boston firm Hacin + Associates, and an obsessive collector since childhood. “I think my husband would have preferred that I put away my clothes or set up the bed. But I couldn’t help myself.”

Growing up on a farm in New Jersey, Jenn found many things worth collecting during long walks through fields with her father: dried bugs, rocks, birds’ nests, pieces of dug-up antique china, animal bones, and plenty of skulls. All of these finds are now framed on walls or displayed on shelves alongside newer pieces picked up at yard sales, stores, and the Brimfield Antique Show. She also has a few family trinkets. “It seems unlikely to find ‘new’ things from my parents’ home, but I come from a long line of attic hoarders,” Jenn says.

Jenn Clapp newburyport collectors home

The couple turned a back-of-the-house addition into the living room using Flor tiles, a custom-made couch, and vintage coffee tables found at Machine Age.

Throughout the house, neutral furnishings and gray- and cream-painted walls showcase the personality of her pieces: In the office, for instance, short black filing cabinets are topped with an arrangement that includes, at least for the moment, vintage signage, collected shells, and a pair of polar bears inside a glass dome that are engaged in what could either be a hug or a battle.

Though Jenn and Greg gave almost every room in the house (which dates back to 1878) some sort of a facelift, they found that it actually required little in the way of immediate renovation, with its open kitchen and dining room, exposed beams, and charmingly chipped painted-green flooring. “One of the most important things I thought about when designing was how I could honor the original house and some of its traditional elements, but also take into consideration my love of a modern aesthetic,” Jenn says. “As I’ve renovated, I’ve tried hard to strike a balance. Luckily, I’m a big proponent of living in an environment that doesn’t feel too precious.” Which is why the green flooring stayed, as did the original wood flooring in a renovated downstairs bathroom where the couple hung orange-and-white wallpaper emblazoned with hipster-looking skeletons, from Brooklyn-based Flavor Paper.

Jenn Clapp newburyport collectors home

A silkscreen print by artist Wayne Pate frames Jenn’s collection of midcentury candlesticks, sourced from vintage shops and Etsy.

The Clapps also turned an addition at the back of the house into their living room, tiling over the existing linoleum with green Flor tiles and painting over an oddly boarded-up window with a coat of chalkboard paint. A middle area connecting the front to the back addition became a library, where more shelves display oddities. “At work, I get to do projects that are modern and clean,” she says. “Here, I get to indulge my quirky side. I really love both.”

Upstairs, the Clapps knocked down a wall between two small rooms to create a sprawling master bedroom, but in lieu of a headboard, they painted the wall behind the bed with chalkboard paint. “At work, we always talk about how the most creative ideas are born from the most difficult challenges,” she says. “There was no way I was giving up a midcentury credenza to buy a king-size headboard. ”

But the real centerpiece of the home is the kitchen, where the couple can be found many weekend afternoons cooking and planning elaborate themed dinners for friends and family. A fireplace adds warmth to the airy space, which turned out to be steeped in history. At the top of the basement stairs are signatures that visitors have left over the decades: “Silly little things like ‘Dad ’78, 83 years old’ and ‘Mack was here,’” Jenn says. When they repainted the area, the Clapps preserved the names and added their own scrawled signatures to the wall.

Jenn Clapp newburyport collectors home

Artifacts collected and inherited through the years—including antique bottles handed down from Jenn’s grandmother—fill a cabinet in the guest room.

Jenn Clapp newburyport collectors home

From left, the downstairs bathroom features wallpaper by Flavor Paper, a mirror from Nor’East Architectural Salvage, and lighting by Jamie Young; in the library, convex antique frames—found in Jenn’s mom’s attic and spray-painted silver—showcase an Uglydoll and porcelain feathers by Roost.

Jenn Clapp newburyport collectors home

An antique whitetail deer mount found in an Essex antiques shop hangs on the wall outside the upstairs guest bathroom, with its bat-themed Flavor Paper wall covering and a vintage game board.

Jenn Clapp newburyport collectors home

Jenn lined the upstairs hallway with framed family photos, watercolor paintings by her mother, and illustrations.

Jenn Clapp newburyport collectors home

A crab door-knocker from Cape Cod Weathervane Company.

Jenn Clapp newburyport collectors home

The library features shelving from Ikea, a vintage Swedese chair, and an antique floor lamp from Machine Age.


Where to find décor inspired by the stories in this issue.


“The Weston” white resin deer head, $120, White Faux Taxidermy.


“Elysian Fields,” $150 per roll,


“Dia de Dumbo,” $150 per roll,


Michael Healy oiled-bronze blue-crab door-knocker, from $100, Cape Cod Brass.


Eames molded-plastic chair, from $299, Design Within Reach.


“Nelson Saucer” pendant lamp, from $195, Design Within Reach.